# Brief a specific garment for AI fashion video, distinguishing concept exploration from product presentation and connecting silhouette, pattern and action to supporting references.

Canonical: https://sharprod.com/en/journal/fashion-material-motion-brief.html
Language: en
Route ID: route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57
Page class: journal_article

## 17. Bound the properties implied by the image

Appearance should not automatically become a claim about strength, comfort or function. If those messages are required, the product owner confirms their basis separately.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.01e2ec07a471f1de

## 25. Prepare a garment-specific request

For AI video production , provide the garment card, scene map and evidence for important properties. Identify conceptual exploration and exact-product presentation separately.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.0893f8f174af90c8

## 11. Plan the overall silhouette scene

J1's first view should identify the whole garment. Choose a position showing collar, length and principal volume. The environment should not obscure these features.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.10d5e48d211353cd

## 16. Treat vigorous movement as a separate question

A sharp turn, jump or unusual fabric motion should not inherit approval from a calm sample. First define what the audience should learn from that action.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.1285889f5836be8e

## 24. Preserve the decisions for the next stage

Retain the material's role, confirmed garment, scene map and open questions. These let work continue when the brand's reviewer changes.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.12fc398363d9e72b

## 10. Describe action in ordinary language

Replace dynamic fashion with a concrete action: turn towards the side, raise an arm to an agreed position, approach a pattern region or move the edge in a conceptual environment.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.152ce7b13ef360c3

## 6. Complete a garment card

Role . J1 example: Presentation of a specific model.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.1a34d6a4d47147f4

## 24. Preserve the decisions for the next stage

This arrangement allows independent decisions to progress while preserving the distinction between image and item. Expression comes from an agreed concept rather than accidental changes to garment properties.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.1bcd9c65d465c224

## 3. State the property each scene should communicate

Then distinguish a product property from an artistic impression. A gentle atmosphere does not establish material softness. A floating edge may be expressive while needing an agreed interpretation.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.1da70b6629aa1f0f

## 25. Prepare a garment-specific request

Name the product decision owner and acceptable action alternatives in the brief . The discussion can then centre on a particular garment, confirmed features and an expressive way to show them.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.20c96f6bc82760b9

## 1. Separate a concept from a product presentation

For a design still in development, identify fixed features. Everything else remains a design question. The supplier needs to know where it represents approved information and where it helps explore possibilities.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.22d3555dd733e8fc

## 1. Separate a concept from a product presentation

A project can contain both. Identify their roles and do not automatically transfer concept approval to the product output. An attractive sleeve in an exploratory image does not confirm the production garment's sleeve.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.243fba1098ca9adb

## 18. Discuss the degree of control

Ask which scene elements remain controlled and where exploration is allowed. The answer may differ for garment, pattern, wearer and environment.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.25952e24cff60e5e

## 3. State the property each scene should communicate

If the intended property lacks evidence, change the message. A scene might show colour relationships and silhouette instead of unsupported behaviour during vigorous movement.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.263dd21046c063d0

## 21. Compare three superficially similar assignments

Their questions differ: does J1 remain identifiable in the agreed action; which design direction should be selected; does the movement work as an image?

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.2a34dfee4e3126ff

## 22. A permissible-interpretation sheet

Environment . Fixed: Not a product property. Open exploration: Space, colour and rhythm. Decision needed when: It adds a new implication.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.2b37c178566c08a4

## 6. Complete a garment card

Unknown . J1 example: Lining appearance during opening.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.2c42bc977a092219

## 4. Map sources to questions

Side silhouette . Useful discussion source: Corresponding view. Remaining uncertainty: Other positions.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.2daa032a662c8fc7

## 13. Plan the pattern detail

Select a region that matters to the brand. Identify element placement and the role of motion. A camera passing across the surface should keep the pattern associated with that garment region.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.2e1e42c43beb2c2f

## 24. Preserve the decisions for the next stage

A concise note could state: J01 and J03 present product J1; J02 needs checking through the side transition; J04 excluded pending lining information; environment remains creative exploration.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.300bbe6c7ff2500c

## 9. Separate pattern, surface appearance and action

Pattern concerns the placement of visible elements. Surface appearance concerns how the material looks in the scene. Action concerns change over time. They may need different references.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.30356be945fb1fbd

## 6. Complete a garment card

Sources . J1 example: Confirmed J1 views and pattern sample.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.3292ac8683c817ec

## 23. Choose a demanding but focused control fragment

Do not select only a beautiful still when motion is the concern. Equally, do not add unrelated actions merely to make the sample difficult. One clear question is easier to inspect and apply to comparable shots.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.370329a5a5d38b42

## 14. A completed J1 scene map

J02 . Property: Side contour. Action: Agreed turn. Evidence: Front and side views. Open question: Intermediate state.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.37458de6b6d24340

## 6. Complete a garment card

Approved . J1 example: Collar, length and front pattern.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.382cfea2c295f411

## 9. Separate pattern, surface appearance and action

Correct pattern in a still does not establish its preservation through a turn. Attractive sheen does not establish fibre composition. Expressive hem movement does not establish technical performance.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.387e1f5d40d759f2

## 7. Define silhouette requirements

Describe visible relationships: body-to-sleeve length, shoulder line, lower volume and collar character. Identify which features matter to recognition in the selected scene.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.3905fe1d955c00ac

## 12. Plan the turn

Check continued identity as well. Smooth movement alone is insufficient if the audience sees a changing garment rather than the same model turning.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.3a9a0958a5014d37

## 24. Preserve the decisions for the next stage

Before handing over the package, ask whether a new participant can distinguish a mood reference from an approved garment view. If they sit together without roles, label them clearly. This prevents an expressive concept from becoming the sole authority for a product scene. The final map should identify not only images but also the decisions each image supports.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.417c135150092087

## Fabric, silhouette and motion in AI fashion video: briefing a specific garment

This handbook helps a brand prepare digital fashion scenes mainly without a new shoot. Its output is a garment → property → action → evidence map. That differs from a general mood board and supports a concrete discussion with an AI video production team .

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.42feea880def0e9a

## 4. Map sources to questions

Fastening construction . Useful discussion source: Detail view and specialist explanation. Remaining uncertainty: Action not shown by the source.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.43d37e76fd3d0df1

## 11. Plan the overall silhouette scene

Decide whether another pose is necessary. If the task is silhouette introduction, extra rotation may distract. If it reveals a meaningful distinction, identify that as a separate checkable moment.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.45f876dd62d062a5

## 21. Compare three superficially similar assignments

The first presents J1 as a real item. The second explores a future jacket inspired by a collection direction. The third creates an abstract fabric scene without depicting a particular model.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.492706f6bef77d38

## 7. Define silhouette requirements

If movement changes the impression of length or volume, examine the cause. It may concern the viewpoint or an actual departure from the garment. Resolve the observation before treating it as acceptable motion.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.4c216007abd56bd1

## 23. Choose a demanding but focused control fragment

After review, identify which scenes can use the finding. Another garment, pattern or vigorous action has different conditions and needs its own assessment.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.539fc503daee1b7a

## 8. Keep fit claims within the depicted situation

State what is being accepted: the selected image, correspondence with a particular reference or a conceptual treatment. If a specific fit configuration matters, supply appropriate information and a specialist who can confirm it.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.556d040c01653b34

## 4. Map sources to questions

Front appearance . Useful discussion source: Confirmed garment view. Remaining uncertainty: Hidden surfaces.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.5597e563ee965da1

## 16. Treat vigorous movement as a separate question

A bounded sample of the demanding action can inform whether to continue, revise the scene or choose another preparation route.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.571c491273029ee1

## 5. A hypothetical jacket J1

Each scene has a different concern: relationships between parts in the overall view, transition into the side view and pattern preservation in the detail. One general quality comment cannot replace this action map.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.5aba8d78ab362ed8

## 2. Identify the garment

Name recognisable features: shoulder line, collar, length, pockets, fastening and pattern. List what matters to the intended scenes rather than every possible detail.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.5e27cfaee17941f6

## 13. Plan the pattern detail

Do not replace an approved pattern with a similar mood. A concept may permit that discussion; a J1 product presentation changes a defining feature if it does so.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.5f930bb1d6a5b8ca

## 14. A completed J1 scene map

J04 is not ready merely because it appears in the plan. The table identifies a dependency to resolve or remove deliberately.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.60232e1f126d6603

## 18. Discuss the degree of control

The buyer need not prescribe software. Understand which features can be revised specifically and what must be reconsidered when product references change.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.69dde4a8e6ca2bd5

## 14. A completed J1 scene map

J01 . Property: Overall silhouette. Action: Calm presentation. Evidence: Confirmed full view. Open question: Environmental composition.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.6a2c5cf04a135d3d

## 8. Keep fit claims within the depicted situation

A digital scene shows clothing on a particular figure or conceptual wearer. That specific situation should not silently become a claim about fit on everyone.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.6d6eaa48525e8c37

## 19. Handle a collection change after concept approval

If the final sample differs from the exploratory image, list collar, length, pattern and fastening changes. Connect them to J01–J04.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.7191aaa329952f39

## 22. A permissible-interpretation sheet

Front pattern . Fixed: Elements and placement. Open exploration: Viewing scale. Decision needed when: Pattern is replaced or rearranged.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.7a960eca10676fa8

## 6. Complete a garment card

The card separates missing information from creative freedom. Unknown lining is not permission to invent it without a brand decision.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.7aeb71a52899fbfa

## 10. Describe action in ordinary language

State beginning, ending and newly visible surfaces. A J1 turn may expose a side seam; an arm movement may reveal lining. These introduce new information needs.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.7d2ee90fd033975f

## 23. Choose a demanding but focused control fragment

J1's control fragment could move from an overall view towards the side while retaining collar and pattern. It should contain the moment capable of changing the production plan.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.81311469c7f5d4bd

## 20. Diagnose a disputed impression

When reviewers say the fabric looks wrong, ask which feature changed. Did the pattern move, length change, surface look different or action depart from the selected image?

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.81486b0d0568967d

## 13. Plan the pattern detail

Review the complete appearance interval rather than the best frame. If the pattern supports recognition, its rearrangement or disappearance needs a decision.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.8978506cb5eee4e0

## 22. A permissible-interpretation sheet

This lets the supplier explore freely in defined areas while locating decisions it cannot make alone. It does not require the buyer to prescribe every fold.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.897b75129c1a3bbe

## 18. Discuss the degree of control

If the defining feature cannot be retained through the selected approach, consider another assembly method or a more suitable action. Do not keep searching solely to preserve a technology named at the outset.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.8b4aadb2f80a87e8

## 9. Separate pattern, surface appearance and action

Select the principal question for each shot. Other requirements remain relevant but should not quietly become advertising evidence.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.8c179df2e043f71b

## 19. Handle a collection change after concept approval

Retain the old material's role. It may remain an internal exploration but should not appear in the final garment package under an ambiguous name.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.8d3f1bf9ba4a83db

## 8. Keep fit claims within the depicted situation

J1 can be briefed around recognisable silhouette without making a universal fit claim. The visual image then has an explicit scope.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.8d6549cba71a80f7

## 4. Map sources to questions

Movement . Useful discussion source: Confirmed reference for the relevant action. Remaining uncertainty: Transfer to another pace or position.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.91246ddacf92068f

## 25. Prepare a garment-specific request

If movement needs investigation, discuss a visual test with a specific question. The pricing context can support a scope discussion after the scenes are defined.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.9bb6190c9b670d46

## 20. Diagnose a disputed impression

Different observations require different decisions. An incorrect pattern cannot be resolved by a more appealing environment. A mood disagreement should not automatically change a construction detail.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.9f02feb3bae9eb36

## 4. Map sources to questions

Pattern placement . Useful discussion source: Approved sample or artwork. Remaining uncertainty: Behaviour during the selected action.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.a1408651c5ba92ca

## 12. Plan the turn

If an unknown interior appears midway, obtain evidence, revise the action or restrict the reveal. Do not leave it as an incidental element with no decision owner.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.a21e04f047f4f410

## 3. State the property each scene should communicate

Beautiful fabric does not define a task. Choose an observable feature: front pattern, sleeve volume, hem position, lining or overall silhouette during a turn.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.a72bcac07db26a60

## 20. Diagnose a disputed impression

Compare the relevant region with its source and view the whole scene separately. Product accuracy and creative purpose remain connected without replacing one another.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.aa6e2e2b0bb87405

## 2. Identify the garment

Appoint a person to confirm those features. Marketing may approve atmosphere while a collection specialist approves construction. One person can hold both roles, but the decisions remain distinct.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.b180614683297151

## 5. A hypothetical jacket J1

The brand needs an overall silhouette, a turn revealing the side and a pattern detail. An abstract environment is allowed, while J1 must remain recognisable.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.b22634086952a288

## 6. Complete a garment card

Boundary . J1 example: Do not reveal unconfirmed lining.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.b3a5592368634e5a

## 14. A completed J1 scene map

J03 . Property: Pattern. Action: Approach to region. Evidence: Approved sample. Open question: Preservation through movement.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.b464a3f07599ba23

## 22. A permissible-interpretation sheet

Sleeve . Fixed: Features of selected view. Open exploration: Position in agreed action. Decision needed when: Another surface is revealed.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.b5b3238e265c5553

## 19. Handle a collection change after concept approval

Some artistic choices may remain useful, but product confirmation uses the new version. Concept approval does not make the earlier silhouette current.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.ba97d66aa4e9e5b5

## 11. Plan the overall silhouette scene

Review the full composition. A close crop can locate a defect but does not show whether the silhouette reads at its final size.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.bec3f17e49af8a50

## 7. Define silhouette requirements

Do not demand that every contour match one photograph in every pose. Identify confirmed views and the new angle requiring inspection.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.c7e796e483b418d6

## 21. Compare three superficially similar assignments

If exploration becomes product presentation, record that transition. Obtain confirmed final information and revisit the scenes. This preserves the concept's value while changing the approval basis.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.cb49dde61bccd69d

## 1. Separate a concept from a product presentation

A concept can explore an invented silhouette, unusual movement or an unapproved collection. It is accepted as a creative direction. A film about a specific item communicates a garment viewers should recognise.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.cbcf343641d04e26

## 25. Prepare a garment-specific request

Related reading: AI video product consistency: what to check beyond a benchmark score .

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.d363b05e8e147e04

## 2. Identify the garment

Record model, variant, selected configuration and the source defining its current appearance. A prototype and final sample in the same folder need different roles.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.d3e290f83a24773c

## 17. Bound the properties implied by the image

If the aim is atmosphere, choose an expression that avoids unnecessary product promises. This concerns communication accuracy rather than a prohibition on imaginative work.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.d59b65ce2f9c77e1

## 14. A completed J1 scene map

J04 . Property: Interior finish. Action: Opening. Evidence: Not yet available. Open question: Obtain information or exclude.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.d5fadbe59f5c88f6

## 22. A permissible-interpretation sheet

Collar . Fixed: Approved shape. Open exploration: Visual emphasis. Decision needed when: Outline changes.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.d79a450751cb6442

## 4. Map sources to questions

The table describes evidence roles rather than promising reconstruction from any file. It identifies what informs a scene and what is missing.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.d8df105f092d56a5

## 22. A permissible-interpretation sheet

Update the sheet when a question closes. A newly confirmed lining needs a source and dependent scenes. A designer's revised pattern should not coexist with an obsolete instruction as the sole reference.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.d9b0b6edbd96d53b

## 17. Bound the properties implied by the image

An action can imply a property without words. Unusual stretching or behaviour within an environment may appear to demonstrate capability. Discuss that meaning before selecting the treatment.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.da88c68b835dda01

## 16. Treat vigorous movement as a separate question

A conceptual film may allow interpretation. Presenting a particular garment property needs appropriate evidence and an interpretation boundary. Realistic alone does not resolve the distinction.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.da9d8c311fd040fe

## 6. Complete a garment card

Required scenes . J1 example: Overall, side turn and detail.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.dc1641b829f9e23c

## 24. Preserve the decisions for the next stage

General mood approval does not report product-question status. Conversely, construction confirmation does not establish selection of the campaign atmosphere.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.e6903db688f00528

## 5. A hypothetical jacket J1

The example uses an invented jacket J1 with a distinctive collar, long sleeve and front pattern. It illustrates briefing rather than customer work.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.e771e66c9724e1a1

## 23. Choose a demanding but focused control fragment

State what would constitute a useful answer: required features remain intact, unknown lining stays concealed and the action adds no unsupported property implication.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.ea0b9e8ae47e78ac

## 6. Complete a garment card

Decision owner . J1 example: Owner of J1 product appearance.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.edc872f504f50200

## 21. Compare three superficially similar assignments

All may be called fashion video, but their evidence and approval bases differ. Mixing them can turn an invented detail into a product claim or constrain a concept by requirements it never had.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.edfb4a5e9a9f20ef

## Fabric, silhouette and motion in AI fashion video: briefing a specific garment

Short answer. Decide whether the project depicts a real garment or explores an image. A product presentation needs confirmed features: silhouette, construction details, pattern and intended action. Connect each scene to the property it should communicate. Expressive movement should not automatically be treated as evidence of fabric behaviour.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.ee608dc2a4eab4d8

## 10. Describe action in ordinary language

If a more limited action serves the purpose, consider it. Movement should support the property rather than add difficulty without additional meaning.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.f429afd5e3f2cdb7

## 12. Plan the turn

Identify the source supporting J1's final side position. Follow collar, sleeve and hem between beginning and ending.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.f5601bd3bbf258e7

## 22. A permissible-interpretation sheet

Lining . Fixed: Unconfirmed. Open exploration: Excluded from exploration. Decision needed when: Before any reveal.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.fd7a12359903c372

## 6. Complete a garment card

Open exploration . J1 example: Abstract environment and transition rhythm.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.main_answer.fe4c92727a3d6e10

## 15. Consider body and object contact

A hand at the fastening may imply a real operation. That needs confirmed behaviour. Decorative contact should not accidentally look like a function demonstration.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.next_step.88861e687c90e17a

## 15. Consider body and object contact

A hand, bag or support can obscure fabric and alter action meaning. Identify which contacts support the message and which are compositional.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.next_step.a3aaccff6222968c

## 15. Consider body and object contact

Inspect identity after occlusion. Collar, pattern and fastening that disappear behind a hand should return consistently with the selected scene.

Passage ID: passage.route.847527651f6f0aa1cf57.next_step.d37361eb154f0039
